Oh, So "Uncle Mark" Told You Facebook was Short Term and a Sure Thing...Right?
I just don't get it! Watch the video below on the rising fury in the aftermath of the Facebook (FB) IPO and you are tempted to believe “Rome is on fire”. Let’s first examine the facts. Facebook on Friday May 18, 2012 went public at the offer price of USD38 on the advice of Morgan Stanley and other Brokers. Understandably with all the hype the stock traded frenetically reaching a high of USD45 and closing at USD38.23 that same day.
Ok fine…so it was not a great start but already the “financial mobs” had gathered ready to declare the stock a disaster zone. In my own estimation, premature conclusion casting extreme doubt, some even writing of the stock… compounded by an already shaky stock market and global economic recession of sorts and a long weekend to fan the flames of doom, there was nowhere for FB to go on opening day Friday but down.
Ok, so a nervous end on Friday and just over 11% down on the second day of trading and today, down overall just under 16% since opening. To my mind, of course there should be some concern at this point about pricing. All things being equal, correctly priced, the price of a stock should at least hold on IPO barring any unforeseen circumstances. But the FB IPO was no ordinary IPO…it came with unprecedented hype and speculation which means in no way should any well-thinking analyst expect the stock to behave normal.
Not only shouldn’t we expect the FB stock to behave normally, we should also bear in mind that stock investments are usually 7 to 10 years in terms of an investing horizon and determining whether the “carry” was worth it in terms of a financial return. At the most basic level the uniqueness of the FB offer and the long term nature of equity investments must be understood.
If I can understand this, why is this Yahoo Finance analyst spewing garbage and adding to the idiotic commentary and conclusions. Excuse me…”FB has done a lot of reputational damage to its brand”? If you’re in la la land you’d better wake up now for whether you’re a diehard (FB) fan (who has spent every waking moment and ounce of energy building an asset they don’t own) or not...you will know that stocks are a very risky investment so it’s “buyer beware” even if “Uncle Mark” hugged, kissed you and told you otherwise.
This Analyst and the many others I have seen on since the weekend have made me sick to the belly...FB hired a bunch of high profile advisors...why should they take the blame for a stock price that goes down in a few days of trading? So what if some speculators get burnt? That is why they are called speculators and even if you were at Zucks’ party and front row at the wedding and reception, complain all you want but the company promised zilch. So you were punch drunk on the weekend just past and now you are going to sue Morgan Stanley, FB and your hero Mark for misleading you? Come on now!
And what about the 99% and this cockamamie argument that Wall Street “highflyers” have ganged up and robbed them again? What about doing your own analysis and getting independent advice? How about not “betting the farm” on a very risky investment which everyone knows to be true? Forget about “Joe Blow” for a moment though. Are you telling me that Morgan Stanley and company, FB and other Brokers will now experience “push back” from the regulators? Where were they in the first place? Don’t they approve these deals? Yes they do…but they will never accept the blame.
Here’s the deal though. It’s the damn media creating news and hype…building up characters and events when they want to and feeling they have enough power to tear them down at their behest. What great news it would be if the FB saga continued…how great it would be for the media if FB failed. It’s already a feeding frenzy…and the fire is being stoked to milk the cycle.
I worry a lot…I worry about the everlasting economic stagnation and about the financial markets. To me it’s no longer about fundamentals and understanding short term against medium against long term investing. It’s all about the here and now, the 24 hour news cycle and media behemoths who couldn’t care less as long as ratings remain sky high!
facebook,
ipo,
mark zuckerberg,
morgan stanley,
recession,
stock market,
zucks 












